Prize Day featuring Rosette
The Prize Day set was one of two sets released in 1991 as a
mini-playset on a theme. Like earlier releases such as the Gymkhana
and Birthday
Party,
these sets comprised of a collection of accessories and one unique
pony. Prize Day, like Gymkhana, was on a showjumping theme, and
included the pony Rosette as its main character.
The accessories sold with the Prize Day release were a mixture of
accessories sold in previous sets, some re-coloured - and new
stuff, such as the soap-brush on a string thing which has always
struck me as odd. Her heart shaped grooming brush uses the same
mould and is similar in colour to Butterscotch's from the original
Gymkhana, whilst the aqua fence also matches the second edition
Show Stable - whilst the rosettes and jump stands use moulds from
previous accessories recoloured specifically for this release.
1990 or 1991?
There is some confusion over Rosette's release, because her box
has the rainbow design from 1990 - featuring Mainsail
rather than the 1991 pony, Rainbow Rider. Her
backcard story also included two ponies originally released in
1990 - Sand
Digger and Sugar Apple (although Sand Digger
was still on sale in 1991). It seems as though Hasbro originally
intended to make this part of the 1990 range.
Rosette Mint in Box
UK, 1991

However, for whatever reason, Rosette was NOT part of the UK 1990
line. While the reasons for the delay are unknown, it is pretty
easy to prove that one happened. Rosette is not included in Hasbro
UK's 1990 catalogue, which was sent to stores to show the year's
line. She does appear in a promotional booklet from 1991, however,
and this booklet announces that the Prize Day set is "new" to the
1991 line.
Rosette and Prize Day
New releases in the 1991 UK catalogue
Hasbro's list from 1995 also includes Rosette in 1991 and not
1990. So, although the box design was clearly ready to go in 1990,
the pony didn't actually make it to stores till the following
year.
This stop-start on her production may explain why Rosette never
made it into the UK pony comic. She is one of very few UK released
ponies that never appeared in the comic in any activity, story or
artwork, at any point in the line. If she was meant to be included
in the 1990 line, but was aborted at the last minute, however, she
may have simply been deleted from potential storyboards, and not
added again when she actually came out in 1991.
Releases in the UK and in Europe
The lack of comic appearance meant that, for a long time, there
was confusion over her real name, or whether she was called "Prize
Day". Some sites only referred to her as Turnierfest-Pony (the set
name in Germany) because German packaged ponies were the first to
emerge online. She was mistakenly labelled a German exclusive
pony, but she was sold across Europe. But, as her UK box can
confirm, the set is called Prize Day in English, and the pony
is Rosette.
There are minor production differences between the releases in the
UK and in continental Europe - mostly relating to how long the
yellow streak is rooted in the mane. Those found in Europe
normally have a more narrow, defined streak than those in the UK.
Comparing Rosette's Hair Streak
It is possible that this variation occurred because of her delay
in the UK release. It is not clear whether she might have made it
to the European market in 1990. This would also explain the use of
the older box rainbow logo, as the box would already have been
determined. It is also supported by the fact Rosette and Sweet
Clover both appear on the German insert for 1991, but neither
product is advertised here as being "new". They were also promoted
in the German comic in the same advert as the Playtime
Baby Ponies, which were also part of the 1990 line. For this
reason, it is possible there is some overlap in where each version
was sold.
I've noticed that the freckles on my European one are a bit darker
than on the one I picked up here in the UK, but suspect that is
more about batch difference.
The English packaged version of Prize Day was sold in other
countries, including Greece, which may also explain why she has an
earlier box design than her UK release merits.
Rosette's Character
Because Rosette didn't appear in any of the comics, the only
clue to her character is contained in her box story. This
describes her excited preparations for a local gymkhana, helped
by Sand Digger and Sugar Apple, who appear to have been her good
friends. After she placed in the competition, she hurried back
to tell them of her success. This story makes her sound like
quite a sweet, bubbly character - I think it's sad we never got
to see her in the comic, especially in conjunction with Lemon
Drop and the Show
Stable's re-release.